The 13 Best Cigar Humidors for Sweet and Flavor-Packed Cigars

Best-Cigar-Humidors

Even if you don’t smoke, you may enjoy the occasional stogie after a dinner party.

Perhaps you occasionally smoke a cigar when friends come over, even though you’re not a regular smoker yourself.

Or, you might just want to keep some Cohibas on hand for those unexpected special occasions.

Whatever your reasons for storing cigars, you’ll need to keep them at a specific temperature and humidity if you want to enjoy them at their finest.

As a rough guideline, the 70/70 rule can be applied to cigar storage: keep cigars at 70F and 70% relative humidity.

Trying to achieve either of these elements without the right equipment is challenging, but trying to keep both temperature and humidity in check without the best cigar humidor is almost impossible.

Luckily, we’ve curated a shortlist of all the finest equipment out there to keep your cigar collection perfectly preserved.

Now, if you give cigars the right storage environment, you could find they taste better with age. Get it wrong, though, and you’ll end up with a foul taste and smell that will make you wish you’d taken the time and trouble to find the best humidor for the job.

If you have no idea what you’re looking for, here’s a breakdown of what you should consider on the buying trail.

  • Type of humidor: A cooler comes with the ability to store large quantities of cigars with automatic temperature and humidity control. These humidors are usually made from stainless steel with wooden shelving and wooden trim. These humidors are often included with wine fridges as a combo unit. Desktop cigar humidors are shaped like boxes. These cost much less than coolers and are usually made from decorative wood. A humidor jar typically only accommodates 10 to 15 cigars. The airtight seal means these crude offerings are better than nothing, but they are not the best option when you’re comparing humidors
  • Humidity and temperature control: Cigars are sourced from plants. Although dried out, they nevertheless need storing at humidity between 62% and 75% of room levels. Equally important as the humidity level is consistency. Look for humidors with a hygrometer baked in so you can easily monitor the levels. Make sure you can also manipulate the temperature of the humidors on your shortlist. Shoot for 70F and you can’t go wrong
  • Capacity: Desktop humidors won’t accommodate as many cigars as a freestanding model or a cooler. The maximum capacity will be affected by the ring gauge of the cigars you store inside. The bigger they are, the fewer will fit in your humidor
  • Materials: The most commonly used material for humidors is cedar wood. It’s no accident this wood is so widely used for this purpose, either. Its moisture-retention qualities set it apart from metal, and even from other woods. Drawers should always be lined with cedar, too. Stainless steel humidors are not ideal and don’t provide the same authentic experience
  • Seal and lid: This is the weak point of a humidor so make sure that the seal is airtight or you may as well not bother with a humidor at all
  • Extras: It only makes sense to look out for the extras you feel you would legitimately use. Digital displays are very user-friendly and easy to see at a glance. Some humidors bundle extras like ashtrays or cigar cutters.
  • Glass viewing window: Consistency is key when you’re storing cigars. To this end, the less you open the unit the better. With a transparent viewing window, you’ll minimize the number of times you need to open the lid
  • Lockable door: If you have kids or teens in the house, it makes sense to look for a lockable cigar humidor

Right, now you have the foundation in place, you should be well-placed to choose the best cigar humidor for your needs.

Before we kick off with our reviews, it’s worth pointing out that when properly stored, cigars will get better rather than deteriorating. When you buy any new cigars, it’s well worth popping them into the humidor for at least three months for the flavor and aroma to develop. This obviously requires a degree of patience, but picture this: if your favorite cigar tastes great right out the box, imagine how much better it will taste and smell when it’s perfectly prepared.

Dive in now as we break down all the finest humidors up for grabs. We’ll give you a frank insight into all of these units without hiding any of the flaws.

Thebarnaclebar.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 13 Best Cigar Humidors

1. Our #1 Pick: Case Elegance Handcrafted Humidor

Glass-Top-Handcrafted-Cedar-Humidor-with-Front-Digital-Hygrometer

Features

  • 15 cigars
  • 3 pounds
  • 9 x 8.5 x 5.4 inches

Our overall favorite cigar humidor comes from Case Elegance.

This is a small and compact unit that only has space for about 15 cigars. As with all the quoted capacities of these humidors, the maximum number of cigars depends, of course, on the size and shape of those cigars.

If you’re planning to store cigars long-term, regulating the humidity levels in the storage environment is key to preserving the flavors. Get this right and cigars will improve with age. Get it wrong and the taste will be impaired. The onboard humidification keeps RH (relative humidity) levels in the 65% to 70% band that’s generally recommended for cigar storage.

You’ll be able to keep your eye on those humidity levels by monitoring the digital hygrometer.

The tempered glass display top allows you to show off your Cohibas as they sit on your office desk.

Inside, you get a Spanish cedar shelf offering you the ultimate in moisture-retention.

There’s a slide-out storage drawer so you can keep all those accessories like lighters and cigar cutters close at hand.

The enclosure is sealed magnetically, preserving the integrity of the humidor and keeping your cigars stay fresher for longer.

As long as you don’t mind the minimal capacity, this is one of the best cigar humidors you can find, and it’s priced keenly as an added kicker.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Digital hygrometer
  • Humidifier gel
  • Real Spanish cedar
  • Not the largest capacity

2. Runner-Up:Bald Eagle Handmade Cigar Humidor

Handmade-Cigar-Humidor,-Cedar-Cigar-Desktop-Box-with-Humidifier-and-Hygrometer

Features

  • 20 to 25 cigars
  • 15 pounds
  • 7 x 10.1 x 4.25 inches

A close and worthy runner-up in our selection of the best cigar humidors comes from the memorably-named Bald Eagle. What do you get for your money, then?

This is handmade box ideal for desktop use. As with most desktop models, capacity is fairly modest. The manufacturer claims you’ll fit anywhere from 20 to 25 cigars inside, depending on the ring gauge of the stogies in question.

The underside of the box is lined with a scratch-resistant velvet, removing any danger of your desk getting scratched up.

As with all the best boxes, you get a removable partition inside. You can use this to segregate your cigars, or you can take it out completely as you see fit.

The walnut finish is robust and also easy on the eye. You’ll be able to see your cigars at a glance through the glass viewing window. This means you can minimize the amount of time the top of this case is open.

You benefit from a humidifier and a hygrometer baked in. Although most users are generally positive when reviewing this humidor, we found a number of complaints about issues with the hygrometer. All we can say in mitigation is that this is an extremely affordable humidor, and you need to expect some sacrifices at this price point.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Variety of sizes and finishes
  • Movable partition board
  • Non-scratch base
  • Some issues with hygrometer

3. Best Cigar Cooler and Humidor: Whynter Stainless Steel Cigar Humidor

Whynter-CHC-120S-Stainless-Steel-250-Cigar-Cooler

Features

  • 250 cigars
  • 7 pounds
  • 20 x 13.5 x 18 inches

The Whynter offers you a comprehensive cigar storage solution if you have the room to accommodate it.

This freestanding cooler and humidor combined comes with 1.2 cubic feet of storage space. There’s an even larger version of this unit available with double the interior real estate. With this iteration, you’ll have space inside for up to 250 of your favorite cigars.

As well as working well for your cigars at home, this makes a superb storage and display unit for small commercial premises, too.

The Spanish cedar drawer lets you stash your cigar accessories in one place. This is removable. You can also adjust and remove the cedar shelving giving you a flexible storage environment.

The cooling is thermoelectric but quiet. You can tweak the temperature from between 50F and 66F to create the optimum storage environment for your stogies.

It’s not just the temperature of your cigars you can regulate, but also the humidity. There’s a hygrometer drawer allowing you to monitor levels.

As long as you have enough room to house this humidor, you’re getting an exceptional presentation unit to show off your cigars while preserving the taste and aroma over time.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Quiet thermoelectric cooling
  • No vibration
  • Enormous capacity
  • Bulky and pricey

4. Mantello Cigar Humidor

Mantello-Royal-Glass-Top-Cigar-Humidor

Features

  • 20 to 50 cigars
  • 8 pounds
  • 2 x 8.6 x 4.3 inches

Mantello serves up a delicate and handcrafted box perfect for keeping your favorite cigars at their best for longer.

The humidor is finished in rosewood and makes a wonderful addition to any desk or cabinet where you want your cigar collection close at hand.

Inside the box, you get the cedar lining that comes with all the best cigar humidors. The properties of this wood are ideal for delivering a trademark aroma while also discouraging bugs.

The tightly sealed storage environment won’t let in any air or light that would otherwise impair your stogies. Look through the viewing window  and check the humidity levels at any time using the onboard hygrometer.

Gold-plated hinges contrast neatly with the expanse of wood. Overall build quality is pretty impressive considering the inexpensive nature of this humidor.

Capacity is reasonable with room inside this humidor for between 25 and 50 cigars. This will depend on the size of the sticks you choose.

Aside from a few customers who complain about inconsistencies with relative humidity levels, the bulk of user testimony is positive.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Handcrafted from rosewood
  • Removable cedar divider
  • Keen pricing
  • Issues with relative humidity

5. Capri Desktop Humidor

Desktop-Humidor,-Capri,-with-Tempered-Glasstop

Features

  • 25 to 50 cigars
  • 1 pound
  • 75 x 10.5 x 4.5 inches

Next up in our cigar humidor reviews comes a classic and understated box from Capri that’s perfectly sized to sit on top of your desk or beside your wine decanter on the cabinet. If you want to store a cigar collection over time, how does this thing shape up?

You first need to choose from three configurations. Two models – one black and one brown – come with analogue hygrometers. The third model is only available in brown and features a digital hygrometer. In all other respects bar this display, the models are otherwise the same. Hygrometers are mounted in glass on the front of the humidor.

You’ll get the standard desktop humidor capacity of between 25 and 50 cigars depending on the ring gauge.

If you want to gift this humidor to a loved one, there’s an engravable name plate so you can make it even more special.

Lined with high-grade kiln-dried cedar sourced from Spain, you’re getting a first-class cigar humidor without needing to spend a fortune, and without eating up too much space either.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Scratch-resistant bottom
  • Kiln-dried Spanish cedar
  • Engravable nameplate
  • Poor quality control

6. XIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar

XIFEI-Acrylic-Humidor-Jar-with-Humidifier-and-Hygrometer,humidor

Features

  • 18 cigars
  • 3 pounds
  • 2 x 5.5 x 5.2 inches

XIFEI may not be the most recognizable brand, but if you’re prepared to take a chance on a lesser-known manufacturer, you could be in for a pleasant surprise.

If you want a humidor with plenty of bells and whistles, this is certainly not the right choice for you. In place of a regular humidor, you’re getting a simple jar.

You could cram up to 18 cigars inside this makeshift humidor, but we would say 15 is probably a comfier fit. These sit inside the cedar-lined jar and stay fresh for as long as you want to save them.

Made from high-grade acrylic, you’ll get a robust jar with a super-tight rubber gasket delivering a consistent and reliable storage environment for your collection of stogies.

If you thought all humidor jars were low-tech and the equivalent of a mason jar, think again. This one comes with a hygrometer built in, so you can keep your eye on those humidity levels.

For anyone still in any doubt about this humidor jar, you can call in for a no-quibbles refund at any point during the first two months after purchase, so you have literally nothing to lose.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Cedar wood lining
  • Integrated hygrometer
  • 60-day money back guarantee
  • Awkward to dial in humidity

7. Mantello Cigar Humidor

Mantello-Cigar-Humidor-Large-Glass-Top-Humidifier-Box-with-Hygrometer

Features

  • 50 to 100 cigars
  • 6 pounds
  • 4 x 9.4 x 6.2 inches

Next in our list of the best cigar humidors is another entry from the ever-reliable Mantello stable. How does this unit stand out?

Well, in terms of storage capacity, this is one of the most substantial desktop units out there. You should have space for anywhere from 50 to 100 cigars, size-dependent.

As you’ll know by now, cigars need storing at a specific temperature and humidity, and this nifty humidor allows you to take care of both.

You can keep tabs on those humidity levels through the front-mounted hygrometer.

The humidor is made from mahogany for a touch of hardwearing class. Inside, you get the cedar lining you expect from all the best humidors.

Despite the generous capacity and the sturdy build, this humidor is reasonably lightweight and portable to complete a winning package from a brand you can trust.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Lockable humidor
  • Oversized capacity
  • Spanish cedar lining
  • Doesn’t hold humidity effectively

8. Whynter Elite Touch Cigar Humidor

Whynter-CHC-122BD-Elite-Touch-Control-Stainless-Cigar-Cooler

Features

  • 250+ cigars
  • 27 pounds
  • 19 x 13.75 x 18 inches

Whynter make some extremely spacious and powerful cigar humidors equally at home in the study, office, man cave, or even a small commercial cigar shop.

Now, this is a heavy and bulky humidor so make sure you have the space to accommodate its hulking form and 27 pounds of weight.

You can take charge of the temperature by tweaking it from 50F through 66F so you can create the optimum environment inside for the cigars of your choice.

This unit is expressly designed to keep your cigars at the requisite humidity levels. This should be at a range of 62% to 75% of the room temperature. The analogue hygrometer lets you keep your eye on this level with ease.

The removable drawer and shelves are lined with Spanish cedar to give your cigars that trademark aroma while at the same time repelling any bugs from invading your stogies.

The only real complaints we could unearth concerning this humidor mention some inconsistencies with humidity levels. Overall, we feel you’re getting a spacious, long-lasting, and highly effective humidor ideal for medium-sized and growing cigar collections.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Enormous capacity
  • Removable drawer
  • Spanish cedar
  • Inconsistent humidity

9. Megacra Cigar Humidor

MEGACRA-Desktop-Cigar-Humidor,-Cedar-&-Leather-Cigar-Storage-Box-Well-Seal-Design

Features

  • 25 to 50 cigars
  • 65 pounds
  • 25 x 7.87 x 3.15 inches

Are you looking for one of the best desktop humidors out there? If so, Megacra hits a home run with this small but perfectly formed unit.

Like all desktop humidors, you’ll need to make a compromise on capacity to get a unit small enough to sit neatly on your desk. In this case, though, you’ll still get space inside for up to 50 cigars. If these are larger ring-gauge cigars, you may only manage to cram 25 of them in this thing.

The potent rectangular humidifier keeps relative humidity levels as they should be for cigar storage. You can check those levels on the simple analogue hygrometer in the center of the lid.

Tightly sealed to preserve the integrity of the storage environment, you can keep your Cohibas for years without noticing any loss of flavor or aroma.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Tight seal
  • Hygrometer
  • Rectangular humidifier
  • Some reported issues with leaking

10. Octodor Glass-Top Cigar Humidor

Octodor-Large-Black-Piano-Finish-Glass-Top-Cedar-Humidor-with-Digital-Hygrometer

Features

  • 100 cigars
  • 58 pounds
  • 75 x 9.5 x 8.6 inches

If you’d like a traditional cigar humidor with a twist, Octador’s cedar unit is finished in matte black. This humidor looks equally at home with traditional or more minimalist décor.

The spacious interior of the humidor can house between 50 and 100 cigars. This is one of the larger desktop models out there, both in terms of overall dimensions and capacity.

The patented Hydro System keeps the humidifier tucked away out of sight. This serves to maximize storage space without impacting overall humidification. Monitor the levels of humidity on the oversized digital hygrometer.

Accessory storage onboard allows you to keep your lighters, cigar cutters, and other paraphernalia where it’s within easy reach.

The tray is made from cedar and removable for your convenience. There’s also a movable partition wall inside. This helps to segregate your cigars and to optimise airflow.

Although this cigar humidor couldn’t be classed as cheap, we feel it represents superb overall value considering the performance on offer.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Generous capacity
  • Digital hygrometer
  • Removable cedar tray
  • Pretty pricey

11. Prestige Import Group Cigar Humidor

Prestige-Import-Group-Milano-Countertop-Display-Cigar-Humidor

Features

  • 125 cigars
  • 3 pounds
  • 13 x 11.25 x 19.25 inches

The Prestige Import Group brings you this impressive display case cigar humidor ideal for your home or for a small cigar shop.

Now, off the bat we should mention that the overall build quality of this unit could be radically improved. If you’re expecting a piece of immaculately-finished bespoke furniture, you’ll be disappointed. If you’re content with a functional and highly efficient humidor capable of preserving your cigars, read on.

The spacious freestanding humidor has room inside for up to 125 of your favorite sticks. As with all the humidors on our shortlist, the precise number you can fit inside will vary according to the size of those cigars.

Glass sides surround the unit so you can see what you need from all angles.

Inside, you can angle the removable shelves and more readily access the cigars you need from the collection within.

If you want to group your cigars inside the humidor, some simple dividers make this easy to achieve.

A pair of large humidifiers help to ensure your cigar collection remains at the optimum humidity levels for long-term storage with no adverse effects in terms of quality.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Removable angled shelves
  • 4 glass sides
  • Panoramic display
  • Build quality is weak

12. Woodronic Handmade Glass Top Cigar Humidor

Woodronic-Handmade-Glass-Top-Cigar-Humidor-for-30-50-Counts

Features

  • 30 to 50 cigars
  • 4 pounds
  • 6 x 9.1 x 4.1 inches

Woodronic produces an elegant yet functional cigar humidor that not only keeps your stogies fresher for longer but looks great on the desk or cabinet, too.

You’ll have no shortage of space for your sticks with room for up to 50 cigars, dependent on ring gauge size, of course.

Made from a wood veneer that’s built to stay the distance, this box is lined with Spanish cedar, a material you’ll find laid into all the best cigar humidors.

The lid of this unit is impeccably sealed, so once you have your cigars inside at the optimum temperature and humidity levels, you can keep them in there for years without any adverse effects on flavor or aroma.

The hygrometer ensures you keep humidity levels in check, but we found a few scattered complaints about problems with temperature maintenance.

As you would expect, you can peer into your humidor without opening the lid thanks to the acrylic window.

The bottom of this humidor is felt-lined so you won’t cause any damage to your desk or cabinetry.

While this humidor is not perfect, you’re getting an eye-catching box with decent performance at a competitive price, so you could do far worse.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Spacious humidor
  • Tight seal
  • Acrylic viewing window
  • Doesn’t hold temperature well

13. Kendal Desktop Cigar Humidor

Kendal-Cigar-Desktop-Humidor,-Glass-Top,-Brass-Ring-Glass-Hygrometer

Features

  • 60 cigars
  • 2 pounds
  • 12 x 8.58 x 4.65 inches

To round out our quest for the best cigar humidors, we have a traditional and highly effective desktop unit from Kendal. What makes this humidor stand out in a crowded pack?

Well, the cedar interior gives you the optimum environment in which to store your cigars long-term without diminishing the flavor or impairing the aroma.

There’s also a humidifier inside this box, so you’ll ensure your cigars don’t dry out. You can check the level displayed on the front of the unit.

You can keep your eye on your collection through the transparent top without needing to open the box and introduce oxygen to the mix.

Organizing your cigar collection is a cinch thanks to the removable dividers. These are cedar for maximum moisture retention.

This handmade mahogany storage box might be one of the smartest investments you make for your cigar collection this year.

Depending on the ring gauge of the cigars you prefer, you could fit anywhere up to 60 stogies in this box. That should be enough for most small collections.

With a cigar cutter thrown in for good measure and reasonably keen pricing, this is one of the best cigar humidors you can find, and it won’t eat up too much space on your desk despite the spacious interior.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Handmade mahogany
  • First-class moisture retention
  • Felt-lined bottom
  • Build quality could be improved

Conclusion

If you arrived here today at Barnacle Bar without the first clue about how to effectively store your cigars long-term, that should no longer be the case.

Once you scythe through the initial confusion, finding the best cigar humidor for your needs shouldn’t be too tough. If you stick with any humidors on our shortlist, you’ll be able to proceed with a clear idea of their benefits as well as their drawbacks. We like you to buy with your eyes wide open.

We’re also aware you may encounter a humidor we didn’t review. Just refer to the buying guidance up above and you’ll be able to readily establish the worth of any humidors you find.

Take a second to bookmark our blog before you leave today. We have a large volume of entertaining content coming your way over the next few months. Pop back any time you need some advice on kitting out your home bar in style.

Leave a Comment