The 11 Best Cigar Cutters

Best-Cigar-Cutters

Even if you’ve just started out collecting cigars, you’ll be well aware that you need a tool to make clean and precise cuts before you blaze up your stogies.

Finding the best cigar cutters can be challenging, though.

Firstly, the market is flooded with cheap and poor quality that will let you down and massacre your precious cigars.

Beyond that, you may have absolutely no idea what you’re looking for when you’re comparing cutters.

Well, here at Barnacle Bar, we’re here to guide you every step of the way. We’ll be reviewing the 11 best cigar cutters today, but before that, what should you consider on the buying trail?

  • Type: V-cut cigar cutters are becoming growingly popular. Small and lightweight, these devices clip a wedge shaped like a V in the tip of your cigar. If you have cigars with tapered ends, a V-cut model is useless. For all other types of cigar, this cutter works well. The most common type of cutter is a double- blade guillotine. This will slice your cigar from side to side in a single smooth motion. You can find these cutters in a variety of finishes, from stainless steel to plastic. This type of cutter is ideal for torpedoes. Simple scissors or multi-tool cutters can work as a portable solution. These are pocket-friendly, and you could even pop one on a keychain
  • Ring gauge: Cigars come in a variety of sizes expressed as ring gauges (RG) from 20 to 60. If you smoke cigars with much larger ring gauges than this, you should check for compatibility
  • Type of cigar: Cigars come with differently shaped tips. Most cutters work for most cigars, but if you smoke exclusively parejos (round-headed cigars) or figurados (all other cigars), you may want to look for a specialist cutter
  • Size of cutter: You can find pocket-sized cigar cutters ideal if you enjoy smoking a stogie when you’re out and about. There are also plenty of tabletop cutters perfect for the home bar
  • Spring-loaded mechanism: If your cigar cutter has a spring-loaded mechanism, this will help improve the consistency of your cut and ensure none of the tobacco inside unravels

OK, with that basic foundation in place, you should be clear what you’re looking for when you’re comparing the best cigar cutters.

To make things easier for you, we review the 11 strongest cutters in a variety of styles and at varying prices. By the end of today, you should be perfectly placed to start slicing your stogies in style.

Dive in!

Thebarnaclebar.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 11 Best Cigar Cutters

1. Our #1 Pick: Alaska Bear Cigar Cutter

ALASKA-BEAR-Cigar-Cutter-Stainless-Steel

Features

  • Double-blade guillotine
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 62 x 1.5 x 0.12 inches

Our favorite cigar cutter of all the models we review today comes from Alaska Bear and proves that simplicity is often the best solution.

This cutter features a double-blade guillotine that will slice cleanly through just about any type of cigar. You can deal confidently with torpedoes, rounded cigars, or capped cigars.

The hole diameter is a fraction over 20mm. This translates to all cigars up to 60 ring gauge. If you’re looking to smoker larger cigars outside this limit, we review some models below ideal for your purposes.

The stainless steel build extends to the blade and gives you a cigar cutter that’s built to stay the distance.

If you want to gift this cutter to a cigar lover in your life, the gift bag is a welcome touch. It also provides somewhere safe to keep the cutter when it’s not in use.

With self-sharpening double blades and enviable build quality, this is one of the best cigar cutters you can find, and it’s pretty reasonably priced, too.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Pocket-sized portability
  • Self-sharpening blades
  • Gift bag
  • Blades degrade over time

2. Colibri Cigar Cutter

Colibri-V-Cut-Cigar-Cutter,-Black

Features

  • V-cut
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 8 x 1.6 x 0.5 inches

Colibri is world-famous for their upscale cigar lighters, and they bring all that experience and brand heritage to bear on this hard-hitting cigar cutter. How does it shape up, then?

The first thing you’ll notice is that this cutter is remarkably easy on the eye. Although it’s small enough to slip in your pocket, it’s good-looking enough that you’ll want it permanently displayed.

The V-cut design of this cutter makes it a smooth fit for most cigars. It won’t work well with cigars featuring tapered ends, though.

The spring-loaded mechanism helps to improve the consistency of the cut. It’s details like this that make it worth paying a little more for a quality cutter like this Colibri.

The majority of user testimony is positive, but we found some scattered complaints about the unnecessary depth of the V-cuts made. This aside, most users praise the clean, consistent cuts, as well as the ease of use.

Crowned by a 2-year limited warranty and presented in an attractive gift box, this is not the cheapest cigar cutter out there, but it’s among the very best.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • For large 60+ ring gauge sticks
  • Impeccable brand heritage
  • Works well with torpedoes
  • V-cut is deeper than necessary

3. XIFEI Cigar Cutter

XIFEI-Cigar-Cutter,-Stainless-Steel-V-Cut-Cigar-Cutter

Features

  • V-cut
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 6 x 5.5 x 1.4 inches

Next up is another compact V-cut model, this time from the lesser-known XIFEI. This cutter offers decent performance at a very reasonable price point.

Just like with the Colibri, you’ll get a spring-loaded release taking the inconsistency out of cutting. This cutter is super-simple to use, even if you’re a complete beginner.

The stainless steel cutter comes in a choice of 2 striking finishes. The design is not the sleekest, but it’s not bad looking either.

The stainless steel blade can work with both small and larger ring gauge cigars. This is a very versatile cutter ideal for most types of cigar.

The only blowback we could find in a sea of positive user reviews concerns a toughness opening this cutter until it wears in.

The gift packaging makes this the perfect pressie for any cigar lover in your life.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Spring-loaded release
  • Gift packaging
  • For small or large ring gauge cigars
  • Feels quite tough to open

4. Xikar Cigar Cutter

Xikar-Xi2-Cigar-Cutter,-Spring-Loaded-Double-Guillotine-Action

Features

  • Double-blade guillotine
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 3 x 3 x 0.2 inches

Xikar produces a commanding cigar cutter available in a staggering array of colorways. Inject a splash of color into your wine supplies here.

It’s certainly not a case of style over substance either. The 440 stainless steel blades are the hardest and sharpest you’ll find in this class. They’ll stay sharper for longer, too. Many cheap cutters feature blades that dully quickly. These will blunt after heavy use, but they’ll give you plenty of faithful service first.

The teardrop shape and spring-loaded mechanism combined with these blades mean you’ll slice the end of just about any cigar with precision. The double-blade guillotine is accurate and consistent.

Designed for 54 ring gauge cigars, you’ll be able to slice cigars up to 60 ring gauge confidently. This should cater for most regular cigars.

Xikar stands firmly behind this product by offering a no-quibbles lifetime warranty. You can’t ask for much more than that, especially at this price point.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Wide variety of finishes
  • 440 stainless steel blades
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Dulls after sustained use

5. Zertone Cigar Cutter

Cigar-Cutter-Guillotine-Stainless-Steel-Double-Blade,-23mm-Max

Features

  • Double-blade guillotine
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 5 x 1.6 x 0.3 inches

When you’re shopping for cigar cutters, it’s natural to put aesthetics uppermost. After all, if you’ve got your humidor stuffed with carefully-chosen and well-presented sticks, the last thing you want is an ugly cigar cutter on the cabinet.

Zertone’s cutter is a stainless steel gem finished in a trio of elegant colorways to suit. The lines are sleek and lean, and the build feels reassuringly solid. Despite this, you get a compact and lightweight cigar cutter you can easily slip in your pocket. The blades feature a locking mechanism to prevent any unexpected injuries.

These blades are self-sharpening and they operate in a double-blade guillotine.

You’ll make precise and consistent cuts in cigars to 60 ring gauge. If you need to tackle bulkier sticks, read on for a super-sized cutter ideal for that purpose.

Presented in a beautiful gift box, the only problem you’ll have is surrendering the cigar cutter as a present, so resist the temptation to keep it for yourself or buy two!

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Self-sharpening blades
  • Wide choice of colorways
  • Makes clean cuts
  • Not the sharpest blades

6. The Big Easy Tobacco Co. Cigar Cutter

The-Big-Easy-Tobacco-Co.,-Quad-Table-Cigar-Cutter

Features

  • Table guillotine
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 8 x 1 x 5 inches

Not everyone wants a small and pocket-sized cigar cutter, so what do you do if you want a tabletop model to grace your desk alongside your humidor? Well, one solution comes in the form of The Big Easy Tobacco Co.’s desktop model.

The utilitarian brushed stainless steel finish looks better in a minimalist than traditional room. If you have a wood-lined study, for instance, you may want a softer and less brutalist cutter. For modern rooms, though, this cutter looks great.

You’ll be able to confidently cut your way through cigars to 60 ring gauge giving you plenty of versatility. Some users report cutting cigars with ring gauges as high as 70, so you’re spoiled for choice here.

The Big Easy delivers straight cuts thanks to a pair of guillotine cutters.

This is a heavy and bulky unit, so make sure you have the space to accommodate. If so, this might be the smartest investment you make this year to help you enjoy your cigars at their finest.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Straight cuts
  • Ideal for 52 and 60 RG cigars
  • Brushed finish
  • Heavy and bulky

7. CIGARLOONG Cigar Cutter

CIGARLOONG-Cigar-Cutter-Stainless-Steel-Bronze-Engraved-Double-Cut-Blade

Features

  • Double cutter
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 5 x 3.2 x 1 inches

CIGARLOONG might not be a name that springs instantly to mind when you’re thinking of the best cigar cutters, but this is a dark horse well worth adding to your shortlist. It always pays to examine a number of cutters before finalizing your choice.

This is a space-saving cutter that makes a great choice if you often smoke cigars when you’re out. The last thing you need is a heavy and bulky cutter to drag along with you.

This cutter works best with smaller cigars to a maximum of 50 ring gauge. Make sure you’re not regularly planning to smoke large sticks, or you’ll need to shop for a beefier cutter.

Choose from a pair of ornate finishes. The intricate design may be slightly fussy for some, but others praise the antique and retro feel of this thing.

If you’re happy with the aesthetics, this double-blade guillotine cutter offers you a no-nonsense and affordable method of accurately cutting off the ends of your favorite stogies, even if you’re out and about.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Great manual cutter
  • For cigars to 50 RG
  • 2 striking finishes
  • Design not to everyone’s liking

8. Vertigo Big Daddy Cigar Cutter

Vertigo-Big-Daddy-80-Ring-Gauge-Cigar-Cutter-(Original-Version)

Features

  • Double-blade guillotine
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 7 x 2.2 x 0.3 inches

Are you partial to smoking much bigger stogies? If so, the Vertigo Big Daddy comes through as promised.

This beast allows you to cut your way through the ends of really large cigars up to 80 ring gauge. This elevates it above the vast bulk of the opposition capable of cutting no more than 60 ring gauge cigars.

You might be imagining that such capacity means you’ll need a hulking desktop cutter, but nothing could be further from the truth. This pocket-sized cutter measures up at just 3.7 x 2.2 x 0.3 inches.

The plastic and stainless steel finish means you won’t want to hide this cigar cutter away when it’s not in use. It will make a wonderful addition to any cigar collection. Just set it right next to your humidor so you’re always good to go when the urge for a great cigar takes you.

Most customers seem fairly happy with this cigar cutter. The only common negative theme we found concerns quality control. We would suggest checking the contents of your package closely upon receipt. Overall, this is one of the best large-capacity cigar cutters out there, so why not give it a try for slicing bigger sticks?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • For large cigars to 80 RG
  • Sleek aesthetics
  • Great value
  • Quality control issues

9. Tonino Lamborghini Le Mans Cigar Cutter

Tonino-Lamborghini-Les-Mans-Carbon-Fiber-Cigar-Cutter

Features

  • Single-blade guillotine
  • Surgical stainless steel blade
  • 5 x 0.3 x 1.75 inches

As you would expect from the legendary Lamborghini stable, this carbon fiber cigar cutter is an object of beauty that would make an unexpected and appreciated gift for all cigar lovers in your life, an added bonus if they are also car lovers.

You can cut the ends off cigars up to 54 ring gauge with the crisp stainless steel blades on this cutter. The carbon fiber chassis is finished in a choice of colors to suit. The blades are made from surgical-grade stainless steel. Attention to detail is everywhere with this cutter.

The spring-loaded mechanism helps to give you consistent cuts every time.

You can bundle everything in the red leather Lamborghini gift back to make a real conversation piece. The best thing? While not exactly cheap, this cutter is pretty fairly-priced considering the performance and the carbon fiber build.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Carbon fiber
  • Awesome brand heritage
  • Red leather gift bag
  • Pretty pricey compared to opposition

10. Camlinbo Cigar Cutter

Camlinbo-Cigar-Cutter-with-2-Cigar-Punches

Features

  • 2 guillotine punches
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 4 x 1.7 x 0.5 inches

As we near the end of our hunt for the best cigar cutters, Camlinbo serves up a dual-cutter model that’s well worth a second look.

The classic stainless steel finish looks great with any décor, and this compact unit is designed to fit snugly in one hand while you hold you stogie in the other. It’s small enough to pop in your pocket if you need a travel cutter.

The key selling point of this model is the fact it has 2 differently-sized punches giving you maximum versatility whatever type of cigars you smoke.

Lightweight and easy to use, this cutter comes gift boxed as the perfect pressie for anyone in your life who loves a great cigar from time to time. That person could, of course be you!

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Dual cutter unit
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Gift boxed
  • Not the smoothest cuts

11. Galiner Cigar Cutter

GALINER-Cigar-Cutter-Lock-System-Wood-Stainless-Steel-Double-Cut-Blade-Cigar

Features

  • V-cut
  • Stainless steel blade
  • 8 x 1.6 x 0.5 inches

To round out our collection of the best cigar cutters, this V-cut model from Galiner deserves a place on any shortlist.

The body of this cutter is finished in a distinctive zebra wood. You get a dark antique finish that’s easy to hold, non-slip, and built to last.

The stainless steel blades slice your cigar from either side to deliver crisp and precise cuts with unerring consistency. It’s amazing to consider that this is priced firmly in budget territory.

The mechanism is spring-loaded. You can readily operate the cutter with one hand. The blades lock when not in use to prevent any nasty accidents.

This is a pocket-sized cutter that’s a great choice if you smoke cigars on the go.

The 22mm hole is ideal for most regular cigars up to 60 ring gauge.

As well as an eye-catching presentation box, you’ll also benefit from a 30-day money-back guarantee removing any headache from purchase.

For a pocket-sized solution to cutting the ends off your Cohibas, this is a budget-friendly choice that’s well worth considering.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Sleek appearance
  • Spring-loaded
  • Clean, precise cuts
  • Awkward to hold

Conclusion

If you came here today with no real idea about whether you needed a cigar cutter or not, you should now see that they are an essential piece of kit for any cigar lover, as crucial as a humidor or a cigar cooler.

You should now have a clear understanding of the different types of cutter, as well as which work best for which cigars.

Choose any of the cutters on our shortlist and you’re in safe hands. If you feel you’ve found the best cigar cutter elsewhere, pay attention to the simple pointers in our buying guide and you’ll easily determine whether it’s any good.

Before you go today, take a second to bookmark our blog. We bring you impartial reviews of all the best equipment for your home bar and smoking room so you can easily find the right solution for your needs. We update our content daily, so be sure to pop back soon!

Leave a Comment