What Makes A Good Cigar? – 7 Things To Consider

Cigars have been around for centuries, and the art of cigar making is a true craft. There are many different factors that go into making a good cigar.

From the type of tobacco used to the way it is rolled, to the size and shape, there are many different elements that can affect the quality of a cigar.

If you want to know more about what makes a good cigar then just keep on reading!

Major Factors That Makes A Good Cigar

what makes a good cigar
There are a lot of things that go into making a good cigar and this will give you a place to start.

One of the most important factors in making a good cigar is rolling it correctly.

There are many different ways to roll a cigar, and each one can affect the smoking experience.

The tobacco leaves must be rolled evenly and tightly so that the cigar burns evenly and slowly. If the cigar is not rolled correctly, it will burn too quickly and can be quite harsh.

Some of the most popular rolling methods include Cuban, Dominican, and Torpedo.

Each of these methods produces a different type of cigar, so it is important to try them all to see what you like best.

The Tobacco Used In A Cigar Must Be Of Good Quality

Another important factor in making a good cigar is the type of tobacco used. Only the finest tobacco should be used in a quality cigar.

The tobacco leaves should be carefully selected and sorted before they are used.

The better the quality of the tobacco, the better the cigar will be. Some of the most popular tobaccos include Nicaraguan, Dominican, and Honduran.

Each of these tobaccos has its own unique flavor profile that can really add something special to a cigar.

The Size And Shape Of A Cigar

older man holding a cigar up close
These things are important to consider when looking into purchasing cigars as you want one that has qualities that you will enjoy.

The size and shape of a cigar can also affect its quality. A good cigar should be of uniform shape and size so that it burns evenly.

If the cigar is too small, it will burn too quickly and be quite harsh. If the cigar is too large, it will not burn as evenly and can be quite bland.

For example, a smaller cigar will generally have a shorter burning time, while a larger cigar will last longer.

The shape of a cigar can also affect the flavor profile and how much smoke is produced.

A Pleasant Aroma

The aroma of a cigar is also important. A good cigar should have a pleasant, inviting aroma.

If the cigar has an unpleasant smell, it is likely that it will not taste very good either.

Plus, the smell is one of the first things you get to experience with a cigar.

Should Be Well-Made

A good cigar is made with high-quality tobacco that has been well-cured and evenly fermented.

The tobacco leaves should be expertly rolled into a tight, uniform shape with a consistent weight and feel.

The cigar should have a smooth, even burn and produce a rich, full-flavored smoke. There should be no unpleasant streaks of harshness or bitterness.

Ultimately, a good cigar should be enjoyable from start to finish.


It is important, but it is not the only thing that matters.

A cigar that looks great may not taste very good so it’s important to pay attention to what the visuals might indicate.

The color of the wrapper can give you some insight into what kind of flavors the cigar will have.

For example, a dark wrapper typically indicates a full-bodied cigar, while a light wrapper is usually associated with milder flavors.


The wrapper is the outermost layer of the cigar, and it can really affect the flavor and smoking experience.

There are many different types of wrappers, including Connecticut, Habano, and Maduro. Each type of wrapper has its own special taste that can really enhance a cigar.


Cigar in wrapper with package and nuts around it
Storage is another really important part of owning and smoking cigars that a lot of people don’t remember.

While flavor and appearance are important, it is also important to store your cigars properly.

Cigars should be stored somewhere with significant humidity so that they don’t dry out.

Cigars that are properly cared for can last for years, but if they are not stored correctly, they will quickly become dry and tasteless.

You can store cigars in a humidor to help maintain their freshness and taste for years.

Here’s a video showing the best beginner cigars:


Q: What Cigar Is Best For Beginners?

Most cigars can take quite a while to smoke as they are meant to be smoked slowly, so it’s best to go with a smaller version.

A good one to start with is a Short Robusto because it won’t take as long to smoke, it’s smooth, and it’s a great quality cigar.

Q: What Should I Look For When Buying A Cigar?

When buying a cigar you should pay attention to the taste and aroma of the cigar.

These will give you the best description on what the cigar will taste like.

Other features to consider are where it was made, the type of wrapper, and the shape.

Q: How Often Should I Smoke A Cigar?

How often you smoke a cigar is really up to you. Some people smoke cigars every day, while others only smoke them on special occasions.

It all depends on your personal preference.

Q: How Do I Know If A Cigar Is Fresh?

A fresh cigar should be firm to the touch and have an even color. The wrapper should not be cracked or peeling.

If a cigar is too dry, it will burn quickly and produce a lot of smoke. If it is too wet, it will be hard to light and will not taste very good.

Read More: How To Store Cigars Long Term Knowing how to store your cigars properly for long periods of time is essential to having fresh, high-quality cigars years down the road.

Final Thoughts

What makes a good cigar is a personal preference. There are those who prefer a milder cigar while others enjoy a bolder smoke.

The important thing is to find what you enjoy and stick with it.

There are many different brands and types of cigars out there, so do your research and find the perfect one for you.

Further Reading:

5/5 - (1 vote)

Leave a Comment